If you’ve been researching the S-corp election for your therapy practice, you’ve probably run into the term “reasonable compensation” and wondered what it actually means. Maybe you understood the general concept where you have to pay yourself a salary but weren’t sure how the salary gets determined, or how much it affects your tax savings.
That’s exactly what this post is about. I’m not going to go deep on the mechanics of the S-corp election itself here (I covered all of that in my S-corp election post), but reasonable compensation for therapists is its own topic, and it’s an important one to understand before you decide whether electing S-corp status makes sense for your practice.
What is Reasonable Compensation
As I mentioned in my S-corp election post, when you elect S-corp tax status, your practice’s profit is no longer subject to self-employment tax. That’s where the tax savings come from. But the IRS isn’t just giving you a free pass. In exchange, you’re required to pay yourself a salary for the work you do in the business, and that salary has to be “reasonable.”
Reasonable compensation is simply the salary the IRS expects you to pay yourself as an owner-employee of your S-corp. The basic standard is this: what would you pay someone else to do the same work you’re doing? That’s the number your salary should reflect.
For therapists, this generally means looking at what a licensed therapist in your area earns doing similar work. Your experience level, your specialization, and the number of hours you’re working in the practice all factor in. There are salary surveys and Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data that can serve as reference points, but applying them to your specific situation requires some judgment. This is one reason it’s not a number you want to guess at on your own.
Is Reasonable Compensation Optional?
This is the part that trips some therapists up when they first hear about the S-corp election. You have become accustomed to just taking money out of the business whenever you need it as a sole proprietor/single-member LLC. With an S-corp, that’s no longer how it works. You have to actually run payroll and pay yourself a W-2 salary.
To be clear, you can still take money out of the business without it counting toward your salary. This money is referred to as distributions. You want to take out less money as distributions than as a salary. When your distributions exceed your salary, that can draw the attention of the IRS.
The IRS is well aware that some S-corp owners try to minimize their salary (or skip it) to reduce payroll taxes. Setting your salary unreasonably low is one of the most common audit triggers for S-corps. If the IRS audits you and determines your compensation wasn’t reasonable, they can reclassify your distributions as wages and hit you with back payroll taxes, penalties, and interest. Suddenly, you’ll be worse off than had you just paid yourself a reasonable salary to begin with.
How Reasonable Compensation Affects Your Tax Savings
This is where reasonable compensation becomes central to your S-corp decision. The salary you pay yourself is still subject to payroll taxes. Those aren’t going away. The tax savings come from the portion of your income that flows out as distributions rather than salary, because distributions aren’t subject to payroll taxes.
So the salary amount directly affects how much tax you actually save. In my S-corp election post, I walked through an example where a practice with $100,000 in profit and a $70,000 salary ends up with net payroll tax savings of about $4,590 after the election. That math changes depending on what a reasonable salary looks like for your specific situation. This is why the salary determination is such an important part of the conversation before you elect.
The general takeaway is that the lower your reasonable compensation (within defensible limits), the more you benefit from the election. But “defensible” is the key word there. You don’t want to set your salary too low and draw the attention of the IRS.
It’s Not a Set-It-and-Forget-It Number
One more thing worth understanding before you make this decision: reasonable compensation isn’t something you determine once and never revisit. As your practice grows and your income increases, your salary usually needs to be adjusted to stay reasonable. Running a salary that made sense when you were generating $120,000 in profit might be a problem if your revenue has since grown substantially.
This is one of the reasons an S-corp isn’t a DIY situation. A CPA who’s involved with your practice year-round and not just at tax time can help you revisit the salary as your income changes and make sure you’re staying in a defensible position.
There’s quite a bit more to unpack on reasonable compensation: how it’s actually calculated, what documentation you should be keeping, and what happens in practice if your salary gets challenged. I’ll be going deeper on all of that in a follow-up post.
Is the S-Corp Election Right for Your Practice?
Reasonable compensation is one of the most important factors when making an S-corp election, and it’s one of the first things I work through with therapists who are considering the election. If you’d like to understand what a reasonable salary might look like for your practice and what the net tax savings would actually be, schedule a free consultation and I’ll walk through the numbers with you.
