How Reasonable Compensation For Therapists Is Actually Calculated

I will walk you through how to calculate reasonable compensation for therapists to ensure you meet IRS standards.

If you read my last post on reasonable compensation for therapists with an S-corp, you already know the basics about reasonable compensation. You know that when you elect S-corp status, you’re required to pay yourself a salary, and that salary has to be “reasonable” by IRS standards. You know that setting it too low is an audit risk, and setting it too high increases the amount of payroll taxes you will have to pay, which negates the tax savings of electing S-corp status.

What I promised at the end of that post was to go deeper: how the salary actually gets calculated, what documentation you should keep, and what happens if it gets challenged. That’s what this post is for.

Quick note: if you’re still in the earlier stages of thinking this through, you might want to start with my S-corp election post first. But if you’ve already done that reading and you’re trying to understand what the reasonable compensation determination actually looks like in practice, keep going.

What the IRS Means by “Reasonable”

The IRS doesn’t give you a formula. What they give you is a standard, and it’s actually pretty intuitive on the surface. Pay yourself what you’d pay someone else to do the same work. That’s it! It’s up to your judgment to figure out what that dollar amount would be.

For therapists, that judgment should start with market data. What does a licensed therapist in your geographic area actually earn doing similar clinical work? That’s your baseline. From there, a few additional factors come into play.

Your license type matters. An LCSW, LPC, and licensed psychologist don’t all command the same market rate, and your salary should reflect that. Your experience level matters too. A therapist with fifteen years of clinical experience and a niche specialization is worth more on the open market than someone two years out of school, and your salary should reflect the difference.

The number of hours you’re putting into the practice matters as well. If you’re running a full caseload and also handling administrative work, that scope factors into what “reasonable” looks like. A lot of therapists leave the administrative work out of their judgment, but it’s important for therapists who handle their own bookkeeping, etc.

Geographic location is probably the most significant variable. Therapist salaries vary a lot from one market to another, and the IRS expects your salary to be grounded in what the market in your area actually looks like. Not a national average that happens to land where you want it to.

There are publicly available reference points for all of this. Bureau of Labor Statistics data, salary surveys from professional associations, and other government platforms can all serve as starting points. The challenge is that applying general data to your specific situation takes some judgment. This is part of why reasonable compensation isn’t something most therapists should be determining on their own.

What the Calculation Actually Looks Like

Let me reuse the same example I introduced in my earlier posts, but go deeper on the math this time.

Say your therapy practice generates $100,000 in profit for the year. Without the S-corp election, that entire $100,000 is subject to self-employment tax at 15.3%, which comes to $15,300.

Now you elect S-corp status. Based on market data for licensed therapists in your area, your CPA helps you land on $70,000 as a reasonable salary. Here’s how the numbers play out:

  • Profit: $100,000
  • W-2 salary: $70,000
    • Payroll taxes on salary (15.3%): $10,710
  • Distributions: $30,000
    • Payroll taxes on distributions: $0
  • Net payroll tax savings vs. sole proprietor: $4,590
    • $15,300 self-employment tax as sole proprietor vs. $10,710 payroll tax as S-corp

That $4,590 in savings is real, and for a lot of therapists it’s meaningful! But it’s also worth understanding what it’s based on. In this example, the $70,000 salary isn’t arbitrary. It reflects what a licensed therapist doing comparable work in that market would earn. It’s the number the CPA can defend if the IRS ever asks.

Now let’s say a different therapist in the same situation decides to set their salary at $50,000 instead, figuring that lower payroll taxes mean bigger savings. The math looks better on paper:

  • Profit: $100,000
  • W-2 salary: $50,000
    • Payroll taxes on salary (15.3%): $7,650
  • Distributions: $50,000
    • Payroll taxes on distributions: $0
  • Net payroll tax savings vs. sole proprietor: $7,650
    • $15,300 self-employment tax as sole proprietor vs. $7,650 payroll tax as S-corp

That’s more than $3,000 in additional savings compared to the $70,000 salary scenario!

The problem is that $50,000 may not hold up as reasonable compensation for a licensed therapist with a full caseload. If the IRS audits and decides the salary should have been $70,000, they don’t just adjust going forward. They reclassify the difference as wages, assess back payroll taxes on the gap, and add penalties and interest on top of that. At that point, the therapist ends up paying more thanks to the penalties and interest. To make matters worse, the entire balance is now due all at once, instead of spread over 26 bi-weekly paychecks.

Reasonable Compensation Isn’t a One-Time Decision

One thing I want to flag before moving on: reasonable compensation isn’t something you determine once when you make the election and leave alone forever.

As your practice grows, your salary usually needs to grow with it. A $70,000 salary might be entirely appropriate when your practice is generating $100,000 in profit. If your revenue climbs to $200,000 after hiring some employees and your salary hasn’t moved in three years, that may be a problem. The IRS expects the relationship between your salary and your income and duties to remain reasonable over time, not just at the moment you first set it.

This is one of the reasons I tell therapists that an S-corp requires a CPA who’s involved with your practice throughout the year, not just at tax time. The salary needs to be reviewed regularly, and adjusted when the numbers warrant it.

Documentation for Reasonable Compensation

If the IRS ever questions your salary, the question isn’t just whether it was reasonable, it’s whether you can show that you thought carefully about it and had a basis for the number you chose.

That means keeping a record of the data and reasoning that supported your salary decision. For example, BLS data, salary survey results, a written memo summarizing the analysis. These are the kinds of things that demonstrate you arrived at your salary thoughtfully rather than just picking a number that minimized your payroll taxes.

I won’t go deep on the mechanics of building that documentation here, because this is an area where working with a CPA really does matter. The documentation standards that hold up under scrutiny aren’t always obvious, and getting it right from the beginning is much easier than reconstructing a paper trail after the fact.

Getting Your Reasonable Compensation Right Before You Elect

Reasonable compensation for therapists is one of the first things I work through with any therapist considering the S-corp election. The salary determination affects your tax savings, your audit exposure, and how much administrative complexity you’re taking on. For these reasons, it’s worth understanding before you commit.

If you’re trying to figure out what a reasonable salary would look like for your practice and whether the election makes sense at your current income level, schedule a free consultation and I’ll walk through the numbers with you.