LLC vs. Sole Proprietor for Therapists

The decision to operate as a sole proprietor or an LLC is primarily a legal decision, not a tax decision. Is starting an LLC right for you?

If you are launching your own therapy practice, you may be wondering whether you need to form an LLC before you can start seeing clients, or if you should start as a sole proprietor. I have had many therapists come to me with this exact question, and the answer is almost always the same: you are probably overthinking it. In this article, I will walk you through the differences between a sole proprietorship and an LLC, what the tax implications actually look like, and when it might make sense to make a change.

Comparing an LLC and a Sole Proprietor

In short, a sole proprietorship is the “default” business structure. If you start a business, start making money, and don’t create a separate entity for the business, you are a sole proprietor. You and your business are legally the same entity.

An LLC, or Limited Liability Company, is a separate legal entity that you create by filing with your state. This filing usually comes with a fee, and depending on your state, there may be ongoing annual fees to maintain it. You’ll also have to get a tax ID, or Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS for this entity.

But here is the most important thing I want you to understand: an LLC is a legal structure, not a tax structure. I will explain what this means below, but this distinction is the key to understanding whether forming an LLC actually benefits your practice.

LLCs and Liability Protection

Before we discuss the tax differences between a sole proprietor and an LLC, let’s look at the legal differences. Please remember though, I am a CPA and not a lawyer. Always consult a lawyer for legal advice!

With that said, the primary reason most therapists form an LLC is liability protection. An LLC legally separates your business and your personal assets. If your business faces a debt or contract dispute, your personal assets may generally be shielded from those claims.

However, an LLC does not protect you from your own malpractice. If a client files a malpractice claim against you, your LLC will not shield your personal assets from that claim. That is what your liability insurance is for. Make sure you carry adequate liability coverage regardless of your business structure.

An LLC can protect you from other business-related claims that have nothing to do with your clinical work.

Keep in mind that to maintain the liability protection an LLC provides, you must keep your business and personal finances completely separate. If you co-mingle your finances, a court could disregard the LLC entirely. This is one of the reasons that good bookkeeping is imperative.

Sole Proprietor and LLC Tax Differences

When it comes to taxes, this is where most therapists are surprised. By default, a single-member LLC (meaning, you are the only owner) is taxed exactly the same way as a sole proprietor. The IRS treats a single-member LLC as a “disregarded entity,” which means your business income and expenses flow directly onto your personal tax return, just like they would as a sole proprietor.

There is not a separate business tax return for a single-member LLC. Its business activity is reported on an additional schedule on your personal tax return. Not only does this emphasize (from the IRS perspective) that the LLC is a disregarded entity, it saves you in tax preparation fees!

Forming an LLC by itself does not change your tax situation. You will still pay self-employment tax on your net profit. Your available deductions remain the same. Your quarterly estimated taxes remain the same.

Things will change if you make an S-corporation election for your LLC, but that is an entirely different discussion than looking at a sole proprietor vs. LLC.

A Note on State-Specific Rules

Everything I have discussed so far applies at the federal level. At the state level, the rules vary significantly. LLC formation fees, annual report requirements, and state tax treatment all differ depending on where you practice.

In my home state of New Jersey, for example, forming an LLC requires a filing fee, and LLCs are required to file an annual report (also with a filing fee) to maintain their active status.

Some states also prohibit therapists from using a standard LLC. For example, New York requires therapists to open a PLLC instead of an LLC (the P stands for “professional”). California prohibits therapists from using LLCs at all. There, therapists must operate as a sole proprietor or a corporation.

If you practice in multiple states, the complexity increases further.

Before forming an LLC, I recommend consulting with a tax professional who is familiar with the rules in your specific state. The decision isn’t always as simple as it looks on the surface.

The Bottom Line

For most therapists just starting out, a sole proprietorship is a perfectly fine structure. The LLC question becomes more relevant as your practice grows, your exposure to business liability increases, or you start to consider an S-corp election.

What I tell most of my clients is this: don’t let the LLC question stop you from launching your practice. If it makes sense for your situation, by all means form one. However, if you are unsure or outright not allowed to open an LLC (like California, for example), don’t be afraid to start out as a sole proprietor. Your business structure can always be changed later on.

Not sure if forming an LLC makes sense for your practice? Schedule a free consultation and I’ll walk you through the right move for where you are right now.