S-Corporation Election for Therapists

An S-corp election can lower your tax bill, but only when the timing is right. Here's what therapists need to know.

If you’ve looked into therapy practice entities, you’ve probably heard someone mention the S-corp election. Maybe it was a colleague at a networking event, a post in a therapist Facebook group, or something your tax preparer brought up. You probably heard it pitched that if you elect S-corp status you can save thousands in taxes.

That pitch isn’t wrong, but it isn’t the full story either. An S-corp election can absolutely reduce your tax bill, but it only makes sense at the right time and under the right circumstances.

I have seen therapists rush into this decision based on what a friend did, only to realize the added complexity and costs ate into the savings they were expecting, or even ended up costing them more money than they saved in taxes.

In this article, I will break down what an S-corp election actually is, how the potential tax savings work, and what factors should go into deciding whether the timing is right for your practice.

What an S-Corp Election Actually Is

This is where most of the confusion starts. An S-corp is not a type of business entity. You don’t go to the state and file paperwork to “create” an S-corp entity. An S-corp is a tax election that you make with the IRS (and sometimes your state too).

If you’ve already read my article on LLC vs. sole proprietor, you know that an LLC is a legal structure, not a tax structure. The IRS taxes a single-member LLC the same way as a sole proprietor by default. The S-corp election changes that default. It tells the IRS to tax your LLC (or corporation) under a different set of rules (Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code, if you want to get technical about it).

So when someone says they “formed an S-corp,” what they usually mean is that they formed an LLC and then elected S-corp tax status with the IRS. That distinction matters because the S-corp election does not change your legal structure or your liability protection. It only changes how your income gets taxed. Your LLC is still an LLC for legal purposes.

How the Tax Savings Work

To understand where the savings come from, you need to understand how self-employment tax works. As I explained in my article on estimated taxes for therapists, self-employment tax is the combination of Social Security and Medicare taxes that self-employed individuals pay on their net business income. The rate is generally 15.3% (up to certain income thresholds).

As a sole proprietor or a single-member LLC without the S-corp election, 100% of your net business profit is subject to self-employment tax. That is on top of your regular income tax. It adds up quickly, and it doesn’t matter if you take the profit out of the business or leave it in the business. Your profit will always be subject to self-employment tax.

When you make the S-corp election, your net business profit is no longer subject to self-employment tax. Any money you take out of the business, called distributions, is generally taken out tax-free. (A distribution isn’t taxable income to you, and it also isn’t a deduction for the business. It’s a wash that only reduces your investment in the business.)

While this sounds great in theory, the IRS is not being as generous as it sounds. As the owner of an S-corporation, the IRS requires you to pay yourself a salary, called “reasonable compensation.”

Reasonable Compensation: Tax Impact

This salary is subject to payroll taxes, which are roughly equivalent to the 15.3% self-employment tax. These payroll taxes consist of the same Social Security and Medicare taxes that make up self-employment tax. So, while your net business profit is not subject to self-employment tax, the amount you pay yourself as a salary essentially is (in the form of payroll taxes).

This is the part where a lot of therapists start to get confused, so let’s use some numbers to illustrate. Say your therapy practice has a profit of $100,000 this year. Without the S-corp election, you would be subject to $15,300 of self-employment tax ($100,000 x 15.3%).

If you make the S-corp election, that $15,300 is eliminated! But remember: you need to pay yourself a reasonable compensation. If you pay yourself a salary of $70,000, you will now pay $10,710 in payroll taxes. Suddenly your $15,300 tax savings is reduced to $4,590.

Reasonable Compensation: A Primer

At this point, you’re probably thinking: why pay myself $70,000 when I can pay myself $10,000 or even $0 to solve the issue of paying payroll taxes?

The issue is, the IRS has already thought of that. The IRS requires S-corp owners who work in the business to pay themselves a reasonable salary

What counts as reasonable? The IRS looks at what you would expect to pay someone else to do the same work. For therapists, this generally ties to the going rate for a licensed therapist in your geographic area, adjusted for your experience and the scope of your work.

Setting your salary too low is one of the biggest red flags the IRS looks for with S-corps. If you are audited and the IRS determines your salary was unreasonably low, they can reclassify your distributions as wages.

At that point, you would owe back payroll taxes, plus penalties and interest. The savings you thought you were getting would evaporate, and then some.

This is why it’s critical you work with a CPA when you make an S-corp election. I can guide you to a reasonable compensation amount appropriate for your business.

What it Takes to Run an S-Corporation

An S-corp election adds a layer of administrative complexity that doesn’t exist when you’re operating as a sole proprietor or a basic LLC. Before making this decision, you should understand what you are signing up for.

First, you will need to run payroll. Many therapists use a payroll service to handle this, which adds a monthly cost.

Second, your S-corp will need to file its own tax return. Unlike a sole proprietorship or a single-member LLC, you file this return in addition to your personal tax return, and it is more complex (and more expensive) to prepare than a simple Schedule C for a sole proprietorship or single-member LLC.

Third, your bookkeeping needs to be accurate and up to date. While keeping clean financial records is always important, it becomes even more critical with an S-corp.

While many sole proprietors can get away with keeping track of their financials with a spreadsheet, S-corp owners will need proper accounting software, like QuickBooks Online, to track their business activity. You can’t accurately track payroll costs in a spreadsheet, and you’ll need full ledger accounting to complete an S-corp tax return.

These costs — payroll service fees, the additional tax return preparation, and the time involved in maintaining proper records — are real. They eat into the tax savings, which is why the election does not make sense for everyone.

When Does the S-Corp Election Actually Make Sense?

This is the question that matters most, and the honest answer is that it depends on your specific situation. That said, there are a few general factors that help determine whether the timing is right.

In general, profit levels into the 6-figure range make more sense for an S-corp election. Lower profit levels can’t support reasonable compensation amounts, and the additional costs mentioned above will quickly eat up any tax savings left after payroll taxes.

Also, your income should be relatively stable (or growing). It can be tough to pay yourself a reasonable salary when there are large swings in your income throughout the year and from year-to-year.

You need a CPA involved year-round. Running an S-corp is not a DIY situation. You need a CPA who is involved with your books and taxes throughout the year, not just someone who shows up at tax time. Payroll needs to be run correctly, estimated taxes need to be recalculated, and the salary determination needs to be reviewed as your income changes.

If your practice is growing and you are wondering whether the S-corp election makes sense, schedule a free consultation and I’ll walk you through the math for your specific situation.