Many therapists are happy to go from a W-2 job to their own private practice. They like giving up the commute, the caseload they didn’t get to choose, and the lackluster pay. One thing they don’t consider, though, is giving up their employer-sponsored retirement plan. Automatic contributions through payroll, along with employer match, make this one of the best perks that therapists give up when they start their own private practice. Unfortunately, many therapists don’t consider this when they make the jump.
By the time a therapist who started a private practice comes to see me, they often haven’t saved anything for retirement since leaving their W-2 job. It’s not that they don’t want to save for retirement, they just don’t know where to start, what their options are, or that they’re even eligible for a retirement plan as a one-person business.
If that sounds familiar, you’re in good company. The good news is that for a solo practice, the choice really comes down to two plans, with a third that only matters once you’ve hired staff. In this post, I’ll walk through how each one works, run the numbers on a few realistic client scenarios, and help you figure out which of the retirement plans for therapists makes the most sense for your practice.
Why a Retirement Plan Is One of the Best Tax Moves
Most tax deductions involve spending money. You buy the software subscription or pay for the CEU course, and you get a deduction for it. That’s great, but the money is spent.
A retirement contribution is different. You get the deduction, and the money is still yours. It’s just sitting in an account with your name on it, growing for later. I can’t think of another tax move that does both of those things as well.
Keep in mind that if you’re a sole proprietor, your contributions lower your income tax but not your self-employment tax. That’s still a meaningful savings, though. And since your taxable income goes down, it can also lower the amount you need to set aside for your quarterly estimated tax payments. If you want to see how retirement contributions stack up against the other write-offs available to you, my guide to tax deductions for mental health therapists covers the full list.
The SEP IRA
The SEP IRA is the plan I see most often when a new client comes to me already having something set up. That’s because it’s easy. You can open one at just about any brokerage in a few minutes, there’s no annual filing with the IRS, and there’s really only one number to figure out each year.
With a SEP, all contributions are considered employer contributions. How much you can put in depends on how your practice is set up.
- If you’re a sole proprietor or single-member LLC, you can contribute roughly 20% of your net self-employment earnings. That’s your profit after a small adjustment for half of your self-employment tax.
- If you’ve elected S-corp status, you can contribute up to 25% of the W-2 wages your practice pays you.
Either way, the total can’t go above $72,000 for 2026.
One of the SEP’s biggest selling points is the deadline. You can open and fund a SEP all the way up to your tax return due date, including extensions. So if it’s March and you realize you never set anything up for last year, a SEP can still help you. And if you file an extension, you could potentially open a SEP in September or October for the previous tax year.
The downside is that the percentage cap holds you back at the income levels most solo therapists are earning. Getting anywhere close to that $72,000 limit takes a lot of income. If you’re netting $90,000, for example, a SEP will only let you put away a fraction of what the next plan allows.
The SEP advantage also falls apart if you have employees. You must contribute the same percentage to your employees’ SEP IRA accounts that you contribute to your own. So if you want to maximize your contributions, you must also contribute that same percentage of each employee’s pay to their SEP.
The Solo 401(k)
The Solo 401(k) is built for exactly the kind of practice most of my clients have, which is just you. It takes a little more effort to set up than a SEP, but it lets most therapists save quite a bit more.
The reason is that a Solo 401(k) lets you contribute in two ways. As the “employee,” you can defer up to $24,500 of your earnings for 2026. Then, as the “employer,” you can add a profit sharing contribution using the same 20% or 25% math as the SEP. In other words, you get everything the SEP offers, plus the employee deferral stacked on top.
A few other features make the Solo 401(k) worth considering.
- Roth contributions. Many providers let you make your employee deferrals as Roth contributions, so you pay the tax now and take the money out tax-free in retirement. If you are otherwise ineligible to contribute to a regular Roth IRA account, a Solo 401(k) will give you the chance to make some Roth retirement contributions.
- Catch-up contributions. If you’re 50 or older, you can add another $8,000 on top of the regular limit for 2026. For ages 60 through 63, that catch-up goes up to $11,250 for 2026. A SEP doesn’t allow catch-up contributions at all.
With that said, there are a few strings attached. You can’t have any eligible employees other than you and your spouse. (If you do, you will need to set up a standard 401(k) if you’re committed to a 401(k) plan.) Also, once the account passes $250,000, you’ll need to file Form 5500-EZ each year. It’s a short form, but it’s an easy one to forget, and the penalties for missing it aren’t small.
Timing matters too. If you’re an S-corp owner, your plan needs to be in place and your deferrals need to run through payroll by December 31. Sole proprietors have a little more breathing room to open a brand-new plan after year-end, but I still like to get it set up before the holidays so nobody’s scrambling.
Running the Numbers
Here are three scenarios based on the kinds of practices I see every day. I hope these examples will illustrate the differences in these plans for you.
Maria, a sole proprietor netting $90,000. Maria runs a solo practice and files a Schedule C. With a SEP, she could contribute about $16,700 (roughly 20% of her profit after the self-employment tax adjustment). With a Solo 401(k), she could contribute about $41,200 ($24,500 as the employee plus the same $16,700 as the employer). That’s more than double, on the same income.
James, an S-corp owner paying himself a $70,000 salary. James elected S-corp status a couple of years ago and pays himself a reasonable salary through payroll. With a SEP, he could contribute $17,500 (25% of $70,000). With a Solo 401(k), he could contribute $42,000 ($24,500 as the employee plus $17,500 as the employer).
Notice that James’s contribution is based on his salary, not his total profit. If his practice earned $150,000 but he only paid himself $70,000, the plan math still starts from $70,000. That’s one more reason getting your reasonable compensation right matters so much. A salary set too low might save a little in payroll taxes, but it also shrinks what you can put away for retirement.
Linda, a 55-year-old sole proprietor netting $200,000. Linda has a busy practice and is trying to make up for some lean years early in her career. With a SEP, she could contribute about $37,200. With a Solo 401(k), she could contribute about $69,700 ($24,500 as the employee, about $37,200 as the employer, and an $8,000 catch-up). For someone in Linda’s position, given her age, the catch-up alone is a big reason to choose the Solo 401(k).
SEP IRA vs. Solo 401(k) Comparison
Here’s how the two plans compare side by side.
| SEP IRA | Solo 401(k) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who contributes | Employer only | Employee and employer |
| Employee deferral | None | Up to $24,500 |
| Employer contribution | ~20% of net SE earnings, or 25% of W-2 wages | Same as SEP |
| Overall limit (2026) | $72,000 | $72,000, plus catch-up |
| Catch-up contributions | No | Yes, $8,000 ages 50+ ($11,250 ages 60 to 63) |
| Roth option | Rarely offered | Often available for employee deferrals |
| Employees allowed | Yes, but you must contribute for them | No, only you and your spouse |
| Setup deadline | Tax return due date, including extensions | December 31 for S-corp deferrals |
| Annual IRS filing | None | Form 5500-EZ once assets top $250,000 |
Another Option: The SIMPLE IRA
The SIMPLE IRA usually doesn’t come up for solo therapists, but it’s worth knowing about once your practice starts to grow. If you’ve hired a W-2 admin person or brought on associate clinicians as employees, the Solo 401(k) is off the table. And as I mentioned earlier, a SEP gets expensive once you have employees.
A SIMPLE IRA lets each employee, including you, defer up to $17,000 for 2026, with a $4,000 catch-up for those 50 and over. As the employer, you’re required to either match employee contributions up to 3% of their pay or make a flat 2% contribution for everyone eligible. It’s a more affordable way to offer a retirement benefit while still saving a solid amount yourself.
One thing to keep in mind is the deadline. A SIMPLE IRA generally needs to be set up by October 1 to cover that year, so it’s not something you can open in a hurry come December or after the year ends.
A Few S-Corp Wrinkles
If you’ve made the S-corp election, there are a couple of extra details that affect how your retirement contributions work.
First, the two types of contributions are taxed a little differently. Your employer contributions aren’t subject to payroll taxes at all, which is a nice bonus. Your employee deferrals still reduce your income tax, but they’re still subject to Social Security and Medicare, just like the rest of your salary.
Second, the contributions show up in different places. For an S-corp, the employer contribution is a business expense on the corporation’s tax return, so it should have its own expense account in your books. If you’re setting that up, my post on the chart of accounts for therapists in private practice walks through how I like to organize things. For sole proprietors, contributions aren’t a business expense at all. They’re a personal deduction on your Form 1040, so they shouldn’t be recorded as an expense in your practice’s books.
That difference trips up a lot of people who do their own bookkeeping, and it’s an easy one to fix once you know about it.
Which Plan Should You Pick?
For most solo therapists who want to save more than a few thousand dollars a year, the Solo 401(k) is the one I’d point you toward. It allows the biggest contributions at the income levels most of my clients are earning, it offers catch-up contributions and a Roth option, and the extra paperwork is pretty manageable.
The SEP IRA still has its place, though. If you value simplicity above everything else, or if you’re catching up on last year after December 31 has already passed, a SEP is a perfectly good choice. Plenty of therapists start with a SEP and switch to a Solo 401(k) once their income grows. A SEP IRA is also ideal if you don’t have a lot of extra cash to put away for retirement, and you want the simplest option to get a retirement plan going.
And once you have employees, the SIMPLE IRA is usually where the conversation goes.
Whichever plan you choose, your entity type plays a big role in the math. If you’re still weighing whether to stay a sole proprietor or form an LLC, or whether an S-corp election makes sense, it’s worth thinking about retirement savings as part of that decision.
Getting Started
Many clients who sign on with me are happy to hear about their options to save for retirement. Even if they haven’t put away any retirement money in a few years, they’ll jump at the chance to open a SEP IRA or Solo 401(k) once they realize these plans are available to them.
I had a client last year who hadn’t saved a dime in four years. Once she saw the numbers, she opened a Solo 401(k) that December and put away more than $20,000 before year-end.
Choosing between retirement plans for therapists doesn’t have to be complicated, but the right answer really does depend on your income, your entity type, and how much you want to save. If you’re not sure which plan fits your practice or how much you can put away this year, schedule a free consultation and I’ll run the numbers with you.
